Our friend, Michael Rubin, formerly of the Department of Defense, now at the American Enterprise Institute notes:
- On December 15, Iraq held successful elections.
- Election day was peaceful
- Turnout was near 70 percent
- There are, however, credible allegations of fraud.
- Lack of independent election observation has compounded dispute adjudication.
- While the Bush administration has, in recent weeks responded to critics and defended its policies, it remains silent on U.N. subterfuge.
- The U.N. should be criticized for abdicating its election observation responsibilities.
- Each Iraqi poll has demonstrated that Iraqi elections are peaceful and orderly.
- It is important for future U.S. policy to highlight how Turtle Bay plays politics with Iraq, and the consequences.
- U.S. embassy-Baghdad junior officers say they travel to the "red zone" more frequently, but Turtle Bay restricts their UN Iraq mission colleagues from holding many meetings with Iraqis so as not to acknowledge improving security.
- The U.N. is not a passive player. If we do not hold them accountable for their behavior and put them on the defensive, the SG's office will continue to erode confidence in US policy in Iraq and elsewhere.
RECOMMENDATION: The Bush administration should chastise U.N. for:
1. Its failure to observe peaceful elections;
2. Creating an observation vacuum into which fraud ballooned.